Best places to eat & drink in Holmes Beach
1. Star Fish Company
Starfish Company is a beloved local seafood spot set right on the water in the historic fishing village of Cortez, just a short drive from Holmes Beach. Famous for its fresh, locally caught seafood and casual outdoor dockside dining, this unpretentious and scenic restaurant offers everything from shrimp and grouper to oysters and clam strips — all served in a relaxed, friendly atmosphere with views of the bay. It’s a must-visit for visitors craving authentic Florida seafood and a true island experience.
2. The Ugly Grouper
The Ugly Grouper is a lively, must-visit dining spot in Holmes Beach that perfectly captures the laid-back island vibe of Anna Maria Island. Known for its fresh seafood, creative grouper dishes (like Grouper Tacos and sandwiches), and full outdoor patio, it’s a favorite for both visitors and locals alike. With live music, tropical drinks, and a fun, family-friendly atmosphere centered around its iconic giant grouper statue, The Ugly Grouper is great for a casual lunch after the beach or a memorable dinner under the stars.
3. Isola Bella Italian Restaurant
Isola Bella, meaning "Beautiful Island," is located on
Anna Maria Island, next to the iconic Duffy’s Tavern. Catering to Holmes Beach and the surrounding communities of Longboat Key, Bradenton and Sarasota, Family-owned and operated restaurant that serves
authentic Italian cuisine with professional and friendly service.
Ideal for an intimate date night or a large family gathering.